October 6, 2022

Voters were disappointed at the incidents of vote counting machine (VCMs) failures across Batangas province’s districts, cities, and municipalities during the 2022 elections, May 9.

Sherlyn Escota, a voter from San Juan, said that the VCM did not accept their ballots and that the Comelec officials advised them just to leave the papers on a table as they would be the ones to insert them into the machine instead.

“So mga around 7 a.m. nasira ‘yung machine. Medyo nagtagal [bago may pumuntang mag-aayos] so napagdesisyunan nalang nila ipaiwan na lang daw ‘yung ballots after voting para tuloy-tuloy pa rin botohan,” said Escota during an interview with Lavoxa.

“Mga 8:30 [a.m.] pa may dumating para i-check ‘yung machine, akala ko maaayos pero hindi pa rin pala,” she added.

Sherlyn Escota reported that their ballots were not accepted by the vote-counting machines. (Screenshot from Sherlyn Escota’s video footage)

Escota also said that many voters lined up at the precinct were senior citizens. Hence, most decided to follow the instructions without seeing their ballots cast and without being able to double-check their voting receipts. 

“After noong announcement sa amin na nasira nga raw ang machine, hindi na ulit in-announce for other voters [na] bagong dating, hindi na-inform,” Escota added.

Voters in Payapa Elementary School, Malvar, Batangas wait in line to cast their vote. (D. Calosa)

A similar case was also reported in Cluster 54 Payapa Elementary School in Malvar.

“Dumating ako [sa precint ng] 6:30 a.m. medyo mahaba na ang pila sabi ng ibang mga [nasa loob] sira daw yung [VCM], so to confirm kinausap namin ‘yung isang kakalabas lang ng room at naka boto na and sabi nga nya sira daw yung machine,” said Carla Llanes, a Malvareña voter.

Like in the case of Escota, the voters in Malvar were also advised by the Comelec Electoral Board (EB) to continue shading their ballots and just leave them without machine verification.

“Ang advised daw ng Comelec is deretsyo pa daw ang pag boto then ipunin nalang sa isang box yung mga balota, after maayos ng [voting] machine saka daw ipi-feed ‘yung mga balota kaharap ang mga watcher,” explained Llanes.

“Since sira pa nga ang VCM, I decided na di muna bumoto, ‘yung iba ding nasa likod ko hindi din muna bumoto at umuwi muna. May dumating na technician bandang 8 a.m. pero hindi din naman nagawa ‘yung VCM, mga past 10 a.m. na nang maayos,” she added.

Meanwhile, other Batangueños empathized with co-voters who experienced broken machines in their precincts and even called out Comelec’s approach to the conflict.

Sofia Pateña from Ibaan did not experience any inconvenience with her ballot or the machine, but she was disappointed by how Comelec handled the problems in other voting proceedings.

“[It] seemed sketchy to me, especially ‘yung pagsa-suggest na iwanan ang balota sa mga presinto […] as the body responsible in ensuring fair and honest elections, you’d think they find ways to make sure that the voters would feel confident about the security of their votes,” Pateña told Lavoxa

As per January 2022’s Comelec Resolution 10759 Sec. 7, during the fixing of VCMs, the voters may “proceed in casting their votes by shading their ballots with a waiver of the right to be issued receipt” or “wait for the VCM malfunction to be resolved.”

Pateña went further by claiming that the number of broken VCMs and the slow response of Comelec were already enough grounds for suspicion.

“Nakakapagtaka rin ‘yung hindi agarang pag-aksyon ng pagpapalit ng mga defective na VCM, and even the mere presence of defective machines. Hindi ba na-test lahat ng machines? Nasaan ang mga spare? Bakit hindi pinaltan agad kung may spare naman pala,” asked Pateña.

Across the nation, 1,800 malfunctioning VCMs were identified by Comelec Commissioner George Garcia during the elections, including issues regarding paper jams, ballot rejections, scanners and printers, as reported by the Inquirer.

As someone who also hoped for a fair election, Kieffer Maldonado, a voter from Padre Garcia, is convinced that the irregularities in VCMs might have been intentional.

“Ang masasabi ko lang dyan ay maaaring may hidden agenda ang Comelec, hindi naman maipagkakaila na may sabotage na sa mga previous elections and ‘yung tipong [ma]daming VCMs na nasira tapos ayaw nilang i-extend ang oras ng botohan, alam mo na talaga,” claimed Maldonado in an interview with Lavoxa.

Meanwhile, Pateña was disappointed by this year’s election but is still hoping that the Comelec will do better next time.

“I could only suggest [changing] commissioners and [making] sure they are not connected to candidates, as well as quadruple checking of all necessary equipment,” Pateña said.

Comelec Commissioner Marlon Casquejo denies allegations of cheating in the 2022 election. (Screenshot from ANC 24/7 via YouTube)

In a press conference aired on ABS-CBN News Channel (ANC) last May 10, Comelec Commissioner Marlon Casquejo denied the cheating allegations during the May 9 elections.

“[Wala pong nangyaring dayaan], if you still insist, we can still check the election returns,” said Casequejo. 

As of press time, manual vote counting results are still yet to be announced, but many progressive groups and individuals have organized movements to question Comelec’s integrity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *